August 7, 2019
07 Aug 2019

Political Update – August 7, 2019

It’s time for GOED to go

Robert Fellner
Nevada Policy Research Institute

July 31, 2019

The RGJ’s recent report, Nevada got a fraction of the jobs, investment promised by Tesla-style tax breaks, confirms what experts have been warning about for years: Nevada’s corporate welfare program is a bad deal for taxpayers.

The Governor’s Office of Economic Development (GOED) provides billions of dollars in tax breaks to large corporations like Apple and Tesla, based on the idea that the added jobs and investments they bring to Nevada will more than offset the cost.

But that claim has been repeatedly debunked by academic research, which finds that programs like GOED tend to be a wash or, in some cases, a net negative. A study published in the peer-reviewed Journal of Regional Science, for example, found that tax incentives actually reduced job growth and business expansion. The study also found that businesses who received the incentives consistently overestimated the economic benefits they would deliver, just like what has happened here in Nevada.

Unfortunately, while the promised benefits have failed to fully materialize, the costs imposed on taxpayers are here to stay. In an effort to quantify that cost, experts at the Mercatus Center recently estimated that eliminating corporate incentives would yield enough savings to reduce Nevada’s sales tax by 7 percent.

That bears repeating: Nevadans are effectively paying more in sales tax just so some of the world’s richest companies can receive a tax break, like the $13.6 million tax abatement given to eBay for a project which created a grand total of two new jobs.

While free markets require that businesses serve the needs of consumers in order to profit, politics rewards insiders who can afford to hire the best lobbyists. This explains why so many legislators support giving tax breaks to giant corporations rather than ordinary Nevadans: the former tends to spend much more on lobbying efforts than the latter.

There is also the issue of concentrated benefits and dispersed costs. Jobs created through GOED give politicians a great opportunity for free press, while the costs are widely dispersed and thus unseen.

Speaking of that which is unseen, it was quite troubling to read that GOED refused to answer the RGJ’s questions “about whether or how it pushed companies to meet the state’s performance measures,” particularly given the tax-funded agency routinely claims it does just that when responding to reports of underperformance.

Quote of
the week



“That bears repeating: Nevadans are effectively paying more in sales tax just so some of the world’s richest companies can receive a tax break, like the $13.6 million tax abatement given to eBay for a project which created a grand total of two new jobs.”

Robert Fellner
Nevada Policy Research Institute

LETTER: No such thing as a ‘temporary’ tax in Nevada

Daniel Honchariw
to the Las Vegas Review-Journal

August 3, 2019

Kudos to state Senate Republicans for challenging the unconstitutional modified business tax extension. The voter-approved, two-thirds constitutional requirement for any tax increase is too vital a taxpayer protection to diminish.

But on the heels of this legal challenge, one may be inclined to ask: Do taxes ever actually sunset as planned? There’s plenty of recent evidence to suggest “temporary” taxes, in practice, are about as rare as unicorns. Besides the MBT extension, here are a few other “temporary” taxes that have already been, or are likely soon to be, extended into perpetuity:

— DMV technology fee — This $1 fee was supposed to expire in June 2020, but Senate Bill 542 of the 2019 session extended the fee for at least two years. This extension is also being challenged in the pending litigation, having been approved with less than two-thirds support in the Senate.

Keystone’s Mission:

To recruit, support and advocate for candidates for public office who support private sector job creation, low taxation, a responsible regulatory environment, and effective delivery of essential state services.

Keystone’s Mission:

• To focus on candidate support on state legislative races and the governor’s office.
• To oppose any form of corporate income taxes or other business taxes that discourage capital investment and therefore job creation.
• Support limiting Nevada state government spending to the rate of population growth.

P.O. Box 93596 | Las Vegas, NV 89193-3596

To ensure that you continue receiving email updates,

please add Info@KeystoneNevada.com to your address book or safe list.
Click here to unsubscribe 
Having trouble viewing this e-mail? View it in your browser